Comparative perspectives on administrative procedure / edited by Russell L. Weaver, Herwig C.H. Hofmann, Cheng-Yi Huang, Steven I. Friedland.
2017
K3402.A6 D48 2017 (Map It)
Available at Cellar
Formats
| Format | |
|---|---|
| BibTeX | |
| MARCXML | |
| TextMARC | |
| MARC | |
| DublinCore | |
| EndNote | |
| NLM | |
| RefWorks | |
| RIS |
Items
Details
Title
Comparative perspectives on administrative procedure / edited by Russell L. Weaver, Herwig C.H. Hofmann, Cheng-Yi Huang, Steven I. Friedland.
Published
Durham, North Carolina : Carolina Academic Press, [2017]
Call Number
K3402.A6 D48 2017
ISBN
9781611638950 paperback alkaline paper
161163895X paperback alkaline paper
9781531006402 (ebk)
161163895X paperback alkaline paper
9781531006402 (ebk)
Description
xi, 270 pages ; 23 cm.
System Control No.
(OCoLC)981761589
Summary
"The contributions to this book focus largely on the current developments in administrative law in various legal systems such as the U.S., Japan, Australia, Chile and Canada. The dynamics arise from the interplay of constitutional principles and administrative procedures as well as from the cross-fertilizing influences of comparative law approaches to the development of legal principles and rights."--Back cover.
Note
Contributions based on conference "Renovating administrative law."
Bibliography, etc. Note
Includes bibliographical references.
Record Appears in
Table of Contents
Series Note
xi
Introduction: Comparative Perspectives on Administrative Procedure / Cheng-Yi Huang
3
Informalizing Informal Rulemaking / Richard Murphy
9
Introduction
9
I.
Fall from Notice-and-Comment Grace
12
A.
Notice-and-comment rulemaking was easy
12
B.
Notice-and-comment rulemaking became really hard --- and kind of formal
15
II.
Reinformalizing Informal Rulemaking
22
Conclusion
29
Is the U.S. Supreme Court Becoming Hostile to the Administrative State? / Jeffrey S. Lubbers
31
Coda
49
Renovating Administrative Procedure: An Impressionistic Guide to the American Experience / Peter L. Strauss
51
Agency Coordination as Agency Action / Robert B. Ahdieh
73
Regulation as Coercion, and as Coordination
73
Coercive Consequences of Coordination
77
Reassessing the Scope of Administrative Review
81
Tradition and Renewal of Administrative Ex Ante Controls of Legality: The Case of Toma de Razon In Chile / Gabriel Bocksang Hola
87
I.
origins of toma de razon
89
II.
current system of toma de razon
93
a.
nature of toma de razon
94
b.
scope of toma de razon
95
c.
procedure of toma de razon
96
III.
Assessment and legislative renovation of toma de razon
98
Conclusions
102
Misinterpretation or a Productive Diversion? The Rise and Fall of the "Relationship of Reciprocal Interchangeability" Concept and the Possibility of Reception of a Legal Interpretation / Narufumi Kadomatsu
105
I.
Introduction
105
II.
Background: The Kunitachi condominium conflict
106
III.
Standing to sue
108
(a).
Japanese case law on standing
108
(b).
"Relationship of reciprocal interchangeability (RRI)"
109
(c).
Application to the Kunitachi conflict
111
IV.
Diversion of the RRI theory to civil litigation --- A-3 Decision
112
V.
Fading away of the RRI theory
114
(a).
Supreme Court's "simple and casual" recognition of "the interest in the landscape"
114
(b).
"Reverse import" to standing in administrative litigation
116
VI.
Reflections
116
(a).
Reception-Diversion --- Fading Away
116
(b).
Micro- fit and macro-fit
118
(c).
On "Diversion"
120
(d).
Internal Perspective: Right to Claim for Maintaining the District Character (Gebietserhaltungsanspruch)?
124
(e).
External Perspective: Should we call RRI back to the front of the stage?
125
Two Conundrums of Canadian Administrative Law and a Theoretical Turn / Hoi L. Kong
129
pt. I
State of Judicial Review in Canada: A Primer and Two Conundrums
130
pt. II
Snapshot of the Jurisprudence
132
1.
Judicial Review of An Agency's Exercise of Statutory Interpretation
132
2.
Judicial Review of Executive Branch Decisions Where no Reasons are Given
134
pt. III
Theorizing Judicial Review
135
1.
Dyzenhaus and Deference as Respect
135
2.
Towards a Principled Interpretation of Correctness Review
137
3.
Judicial Review's Constitutional Principles
141
A. McLean: Normative Diversity and Coherence
143
B.
Agraira: Normative Diversity and Coherence
146
Conclusion
147
Recent Developments in Administrative Law: The Tremors of March 9, 2015 / Peter L. Strauss
149
I.
Department of Transportation v. Association of American Railroads
149
II.
Perez, Secretary of Labor v. Mortgage Bankers Association
156
Proceeding Without an Administrative Procedure Act: The Australian Story
163
Margaret Allars
1.
Administrative Procedure Act
164
2.
Australia
168
3.
Procedural Uniformity: Some Conclusions
179
Constitution as a Primary Administrative Procedure Act in Chilean Law / Gabriel Bocksang Hola
181
Introduction
181
I.
systematic function
182
II.
principial function
186
III.
suppletory function
190
Conclusion
194
Administrative Searches and the Need for Reform / Russell L. Weaver
197
I.
Administrative Authority to Search: Modern Judicial Interpretations
199
II.
Border Search Doctrine
202
III.
NSA Data Collection
204
Conclusion
212
Taking "Regulatory Courts" Seriously --- A Perspective from Japanese City Planning Law / Narufumi Kadomatsu
213
1.
Conceptual Issues
213
1.1.
Regulation: A relative/reciprocal concept
213
1.2.
Expanding functions of the judiciary?
215
2.
Institutional backdrop: "legal dispute"
216
2.1.
concept of "legal dispute"
216
2.2.
Administrative litigation as a "legal dispute"
216
2.2.1.
"Legal dispute" as a gatekeeper: Subject matter (administrative disposition) and standing to sue
216
2.3.
concept of judiciary limited to judgments on "questions of law"
219
2.3.1.
Administrative discretion and "questions of law"
220
2.3.2.
Relativity of "questions of law"
220
2.4.
Summary
222
3.
Tug of war over the limits of the judiciary
222
3.1.
Relativization of "gatekeeper" function
223
3.1.1.
Administrative disposition
223
3.1.2.
Standing to sue
224
3.2.
Possibilities for more active intervention
225
3.2.1.
Determination of facts and prognosis
225
3.2.2.
Interpretation of law and "judgment making process control"
227
4.
Conclusion
230
Chevron with Teeth: Judicial Deference and Information Elicitation / Cheng-Yi Huang
231
1.
Disarray or Disaggregation --- Judicial deference in post-Mead Era
232
2.
Unfolding Judicial Deference
239
2.1.
Judicial Deference under Express Legislative Delegation
240
2.2.
Judicial Deference under Implicit Legislative Delegation
242
3.
Judicial Deference and the Elicitation of Information
246
3.1.
Deference as Rule vs. Deference as Standard
246
3.2.
Legal Mechanisms for Information Elicitation and Circulation in the Post-Mead Era
249
4.
Conclusion
253
Proliferation of Administrative Searches in the Modern Administrative State / Russell L. Weaver
255
I.
Fourth Amendment and Administrative Searches During the Colonial Period
256
II.
Supreme Court and Administrative Inspections
259
III.
Conundrum Presented by the Court's Administrative Search Jurisprudence
261
IV.
Proliferating Searches by Administrative Officials 266 Conclusion
269