Interaction and delimitation of international legal orders / by Maria Fogdestam Agius.
2014
KZ3410 .A35 2014 (Map It)
Available at Cellar
Formats
| Format | |
|---|---|
| BibTeX | |
| MARCXML | |
| TextMARC | |
| MARC | |
| DublinCore | |
| EndNote | |
| NLM | |
| RefWorks | |
| RIS |
Items
Details
Title
Interaction and delimitation of international legal orders / by Maria Fogdestam Agius.
Published
Leiden : Brill Nijhoff, [2014]
Call Number
KZ3410 .A35 2014
ISBN
9789004272064 (hardback : alk. paper)
9004272062 (hardback : alk. paper)
9789004283497 (e-book)
9004283498 (e-book)
9004272062 (hardback : alk. paper)
9789004283497 (e-book)
9004283498 (e-book)
Description
xiii, 555 pages ; 25 cm.
System Control No.
(OCoLC)890912699
Bibliography, etc. Note
Includes bibliographical references (pages 515-549) and index.
Record Appears in
Table of Contents
Abbreviations and Acronyms
vii
Main Cited Instruments
xi
1.
Introduction
1
1.1.
Purpose
1
1.2.
Outline of Argument
4
1.2.1.
Fragmentation and Integration as Drivers of International Law
4
1.2.2.
Allocation of Authority between Law-Applying Institutions
6
1.2.3.
Integration and Extended Interpretative Competence
12
1.2.4.
The Role of Courts and the Legitimacy of Regime Interaction
13
1.3.
Research Design
14
1.4.
Scope and Delimitations
19
1.5.
Note on Terms and Definitions
24
1.6.
Outline of the Book
26
2.
Treaty Regimes in International Law
28
2.1.
The Choice for Regimes
28
2.2.
Exodus from International Law
37
2.2.1.
Confined by Unity, Delimited by Diversity
37
2.2.2.
Regime Establishment
39
2.2.3.
Informal Regime Creation
45
3.
General International Law as Applied in International Regimes
56
3.1.
Introduction
56
3.2.
Status of General International Law in the Sources of Law of Regimes
59
3.3.
Varieties of General Norms Relied Upon in Adjudicative Practice
75
3.3.1.
Rules on the Creation, Scope, Modification and Termination of Treaties
75
3.3.2.
Rules on the Interpretation of Treaties
82
3.3.3.
Rules on State Responsibility
90
3.3.4.
Rules on Judicial Powers and Judicial Procedure
97
3.3.5.
Substantive Principles of Customary International Law
102
3.4.
Observations and Implications
114
4.
Invocation of Extrinsic Rules of Conventional Law
131
4.1.
Introduction
131
4.2.
The Trade-Environment Interface
153
4.2.1.
Balancing Trade and Environmental Concerns under WTO Rules
153
4.2.2.
References to Environmental Norms in WTO Proceedings
162
4.2.3.
Revisiting the Relationship between WTO Rules and MEA Provisions
172
4.3.
The Interface between EU Law and Environmental Law
174
4.3.1.
Environmental Concerns in EU Law
174
4.3.2.
References to Environmental Norms in Proceedings before EU Courts
177
4.4.
The EU-WHO interface
193
4.4.1.
The Intervening Structure of the EU Legal Regime
193
4.4.2.
References to WTO Rules before EU Courts
194
4.4.3.
The Creation of the EU Legal Order and Institutions through Interaction with the WTO?
204
4.5.
The Interface between the Law of the Sea and EU Law
212
4.5.1.
Applicability of Law of the Sea Rules to Challenge EU Legislation
212
4.5.2.
Applicability of UNCLOS to Defend a Breach of EU Law
221
4.5.3.
References to UNCLOS to Delimit Jurisdictional Rights and Scope of Application of EU Law in Various Maritime Zones
223
4.6.
Observations and Implications
229
4.6.1.
Temporal Dimensions and Multi-Sourced Norms
229
4.6.2.
Creation of Conflicting Obligations
230
4.6.3.
`Muted Dialogue'
233
5.
Invocation of Extrinsic Judgments and Decisions
235
5.1.
Introduction
235
5.2.
References to General International Courts
236
5.3.
Invocation of EU Judgments in WTO Proceedings
242
5.4.
Assessment under EU Law of Interpretations by Other Courts
253
5.5.
Invocation of Extrinsic Ruling on Incompatibility as Grounds for Annulment or Damages
265
5.6.
Standard-setting and Decisions by Non-Judicial Bodies in Other Fora Used as Background
281
5.7.
Observations and Implications
282
6.
Extrinsically Informed Interpretation
285
6.1.
Introduction
285
6.2.
Systemic Integration and Interaction through Interpretation
289
6.3.
Extrinsic Norms as Prejudicial Fact or Evidence of Fact
348
6.4.
Interpretation of Substantive Rules in Light of Extrinsic Norms
369
6.5.
Extrinsic Rules as Evidence of an Ordinary Meaning of Treaty Terms
381
6.6.
Extrinsic Rules as Providing Background and Context for the Dispute or as Indicating the State of International Affairs
390
6.7.
Invocation of Extrinsic Rules Incorporated or Implemented in the Regime
402
6.8.
Qualifying the Use of Extrinsic Norms
415
7.
Observations and Conclusions
434
7.1.
Framing Decisions as Indicators of Regime Delimitation
434
7.2.
Implications for Regime Delimitation: Regime-Specific Rules of Recognition and Claims to Constitutionality
471
7.3.
Reconstruction and Reinterpretation
487
7.4.
Creation of Inter-Regime Relationships
494
7.5.
Foundations of Authority and the Legitimacy of International Law
499
7.5.1.
Evolving Regimes and Authority Fragmentation
499
7.5.2.
Validity, Legitimacy, and Authority of International Treaty Regime Institutions
510
List of References
515
Cited Literature and Reports
515
Cited Judgments, Decisions and Opinions
529
Index
550