An inquiry into the existence of global values : through the lens of comparative constitutional law / edited by Dennis Davis, Alan Richter and Cheryl Saunders.
2015
K3165 .I57 2015 (Map It)
Available at Cellar
Formats
Format | |
---|---|
BibTeX | |
MARCXML | |
TextMARC | |
MARC | |
DublinCore | |
EndNote | |
NLM | |
RefWorks | |
RIS |
Items
Details
Title
An inquiry into the existence of global values : through the lens of comparative constitutional law / edited by Dennis Davis, Alan Richter and Cheryl Saunders.
Published
Oxford, United Kingdom : Hart Publishing, 2015.
Copyright
©2015
Call Number
K3165 .I57 2015
ISBN
9781841138558
184113855X
184113855X
Description
xvi, 493 pages ; 24 cm.
System Control No.
(OCoLC)913851330
Summary
The world appears to be globalising economically, technologically and even, to a halting extent, politically. This process of globalisation raises the possibility of an international legal framework, a possibility which has gained pressing relevance in the wake of the recent global economic crisis. But for any international legal framework to exist, normative agreement between countries, with very differing political, economic, cultural and legal traditions, becomes necessary. This work explores the possibility of such a normative agreement through the prism of national constitutional norms. Since 1945, more than a hundred countries have adopted constitutional texts which incorporate, at least in part, a Bill of Rights. These texts reveal significant similarities, which are examined in this book. From these national studies the work analyses the rise of constitutionalism since WWII, and charts the possibility of a consensus of values which might plausibly underpin an effective and legitimate international legal order.-- Provided by publisher.
Bibliography, etc. Note
Includes bibliographical references and index.
Record Appears in
Gift
Purchased from the income of the Szladits Fund
Gift

The Arthur W. Diamond Law Library
Purchased from the income of the Szladits Fund
Table of Contents
List of Contributors
xv
1.
Introduction
1
I.
Outline of Project / Dennis Davis Cheryl Saunders Alan Richter
1
II.
Comparative Law and Constitutionalism / Dennis Davis Cheryl Saunders Alan Richter
3
III.
Constitutional Systems-Convergence and Particularism / Dennis Davis Cheryl Saunders Alan Richter
5
IV.
Identifying Constitutional Systems for Comparison / Dennis Davis Cheryl Saunders Alan Richter
8
V.
Defining Values / Dennis Davis Cheryl Saunders Alan Richter
10
2.
Values in Australian Constitutionalism / Dennis Davis Cheryl Saunders Alan Richter
15
I.
Australian Dilemma / Megan Donaldson Cheryl Saunders
15
II.
Australian Context: Meaning and Sources of 'Values' / Megan Donaldson Cheryl Saunders
18
III.
Which Values? / Megan Donaldson Cheryl Saunders
27
A.
Review of Listed Values / Megan Donaldson Cheryl Saunders
27
i.
Justice/Fairness / Megan Donaldson Cheryl Saunders
27
ii.
Equality / Megan Donaldson Cheryl Saunders
34
iii.
Community / Megan Donaldson Cheryl Saunders
38
iv.
Freedom/Independence / Megan Donaldson Cheryl Saunders
42
v.
Responsibility/Accountability and Integrity/Honesty / Megan Donaldson Cheryl Saunders
45
vi.
Respect/Tolerance / Megan Donaldson Cheryl Saunders
50
vii.
Participation/Inclusion / Megan Donaldson Cheryl Saunders
53
viii.
Security / Megan Donaldson Cheryl Saunders
53
ix.
Life / Megan Donaldson Cheryl Saunders
55
x.
Dignity / Megan Donaldson Cheryl Saunders
56
xi.
Compassion/Caring / Megan Donaldson Cheryl Saunders
57
xii.
Family / Megan Donaldson Cheryl Saunders
58
xiii.
Environment / Megan Donaldson Cheryl Saunders
58
B.
Priority of Values / Megan Donaldson Cheryl Saunders
59
IV.
Congruence / Megan Donaldson Cheryl Saunders
60
3.
Global Values and Local Realities: Brazilian Constitutional Law / Megan Donaldson Cheryl Saunders
67
I.
Values in Brazilian Constitutional History / Florian F. Hoffmann Feibio Carvalho Leite
67
II.
Finding Values in Constitutional Law / Florian F. Hoffmann Feibio Carvalho Leite
71
A.
Legal Infrastructure and Legal Culture / Florian F. Hoffmann Feibio Carvalho Leite
71
B.
Values in the Constitutional Text and Jurisprudence / Florian F. Hoffmann Feibio Carvalho Leite
74
i.
Constitutional (Value) Architecture / Florian F. Hoffmann Feibio Carvalho Leite
74
ii.
Jurisprudence / Florian F. Hoffmann Feibio Carvalho Leite
75
III.
Conclusion: Values Between Constitutional Ideal and Reality / Florian F. Hoffmann Feibio Carvalho Leite
88
4.
Canada / Florian F. Hoffmann Feibio Carvalho Leite
93
I.
Context: Historical Background and Pre-Charter Values / Lorraine F. Weinrib
93
II.
Values and their Prioritisation / Lorraine F. Weinrib
97
A.
Normative Framework / Lorraine F. Weinrib
98
B.
Court and Nationhood: Respecting Diversity / Lorraine F. Weinrib
100
C.
Language / Lorraine F. Weinrib
102
D.
Individual Protection / Lorraine F. Weinrib
103
E.
Democracy and Rights / Lorraine F. Weinrib
105
F.
Dignity: the Core Value / Lorraine F. Weinrib
106
G.
Expression / Lorraine F. Weinrib
108
H.
Political Rights / Lorraine F. Weinrib
109
I.
Rights to Life / Lorraine F. Weinrib
110
J.
Death Penalty / Lorraine F. Weinrib
111
K.
Liberty / Lorraine F. Weinrib
112
L.
Equality / Lorraine F. Weinrib
113
III.
Congruence and Incongruence / Lorraine F. Weinrib
114
A.
Particular Canadian Solution / Lorraine F. Weinrib
115
5.
Constitutions and Values in Three Chinese Societies / Lorraine F. Weinrib
119
I.
Introduction / Albert H.Y. Chen
119
II.
Historical and Ideological Contexts / Albert H.Y. Chen
120
A.
ROC Constitution / Albert H.Y. Chen
120
B.
PRC Constitution / Albert H.Y. Chen
122
C.
Basic Law of the HKSAR / Albert H.Y. Chen
124
III.
Political Systems Concerned / Albert H.Y. Chen
125
A.
Taiwan / Albert H.Y. Chen
125
B.
PRC / Albert H.Y. Chen
127
C.
HKSAR / Albert H.Y. Chen
128
IV.
Values in the Three Constitutional Texts / Albert H.Y. Chen
130
A.
Life / Albert H.Y. Chen
130
B.
Dignity / Albert H.Y. Chen
131
C.
Security / Albert H.Y. Chen
131
D.
Freedom (or Liberty) / Albert H.Y. Chen
132
E.
Privacy / Albert H.Y. Chen
133
F.
Equality / Albert H.Y. Chen
134
G.
Justice and Fairness / Albert H.Y. Chen
135
H.
Respect and Tolerance / Albert H.Y. Chen
137
I.
Family / Albert H.Y. Chen
138
J.
Work / Albert H.Y. Chen
138
K.
Property / Albert H.Y. Chen
139
L.
Community / Albert H.Y. Chen
140
M.
Compassion and Solidarity / Albert H.Y. Chen
141
N.
Education / Albert H.Y. Chen
142
O.
Environment / Albert H.Y. Chen
144
P.
Peace / Albert H.Y. Chen
145
Q.
Responsibility and Accountability / Albert H.Y. Chen
145
R.
Participation / Albert H.Y. Chen
146
S.
Honesty and Integrity / Albert H.Y. Chen
148
V.
Prioritisation and Congruence / Albert H.Y. Chen
148
A.
Prioritisation of Values in the Constitutional Texts / Albert H.Y. Chen
148
B.
Congruence Between Constitutionally Proclaimed Values and Social and Political Reality / Albert H.Y. Chen
150
VI.
Conclusion / Albert H.Y. Chen
152
6.
Human Dignity, Individual Rights and Equality: The Core Values of the Finnish Constitutional Act / Albert H.Y. Chen
155
I.
Introduction / Martta October Riikka Salonen
155
A.
Constitutional Processes at the Gaining of Independence 1809-1917 / Riikka Salonen Martta October
156
B.
Development of Finnish Constitutionalism 1917-90 / Riikka Salonen Martta October
157
C.
Reformed Finnish Constitution 1995-2000 / Riikka Salonen Martta October
158
II.
Explicit and Implicit Cultural Values of the Finnish Constitutional Act / Riikka Salonen Martta October
160
A.
Human Dignity, Democracy and Rule of Law / Riikka Salonen Martta October
160
B.
Equality and Equity / Riikka Salonen Martta October
161
C.
Justice and Freedom / Riikka Salonen Martta October
164
D.
Inclusion and Community / Riikka Salonen Martta October
166
E.
Peace, Life, Integrity and Security / Riikka Salonen Martta October
167
F.
Compassion and Environment / Riikka Salonen Martta October
168
III.
Law in Action-Do the Values Expressed in the Text Conform with Reality? / Riikka Salonen Martta October
169
A.
Supervision of the Compliance with the Constitution / Riikka Salonen Martta October
169
B.
Challenges of the Present Practice of National Basic and Human Rights Policies / Riikka Salonen Martta October
170
C.
Equality Provisions in Action / Riikka Salonen Martta October
171
D.
More to be Done on Inclusion / Riikka Salonen Martta October
173
IV.
Conclusion / Riikka Salonen Martta October
174
7.
Constitutional and Legal Framework for Rights Protection in France / Martta October Riikka Salonen
177
I.
Sources / Michel Troper
177
II.
Terms 'Values' and 'Principles' / Michel Troper
182
III.
Values / Michel Troper
185
A.
Values Mentioned in Constitutional Documents in Terms Identical or Analogous to those of the List / Michel Troper
185
B.
Values that Relate or are Comparable to some of the List, Although Formulated in Different Words / Michel Troper
187
C.
Values that Never Appear either in Fundamental Documents or in Court Interpretations / Michel Troper
187
D.
Values which are not on the List, but are Mentioned Very Frequently in Constitutional Documents / Michel Troper
188
IV.
Prioritisation / Michel Troper
191
V.
Congruence / Michel Troper
194
8.
Values in German Constitutional Law / Michel Troper
199
I.
Constitutions and Values / Dieter Grimm
199
II.
Values in the German Constitution / Dieter Grimm
199
A.
General Survey / Dieter Grimm
199
III.
Values in the Basic Law / Dieter Grimm
203
IV.
Understanding the Text / Dieter Grimm
204
V.
Prioritisation / Dieter Grimm
212
VI.
Congruence / Dieter Grimm
213
9.
Crafting Constitutional Values: An Examination of the Supreme Court of India / Dieter Grimm
215
I.
Constitution of India, 1950 / Menaka Guruswamy
216
A.
Power of the Supreme Court Under the Constitution / Menaka Guruswamy
217
B.
Emergence of the Supreme Court as a Value Crafter / Menaka Guruswamy
218
II.
Constitutions, Values and the People / Menaka Guruswamy
220
A.
Preamble of the Indian Constitution-Values of We the People / Menaka Guruswamy
222
III.
Fundamental Rights / Menaka Guruswamy
224
A.
Directive Principles of State Policy / Menaka Guruswamy
225
B.
Right to Life: A Right that Encompasses All / Menaka Guruswamy
226
C.
Right to Education / Menaka Guruswamy
229
D.
Family/Community / Menaka Guruswamy
232
E.
Freedom/Independence / Menaka Guruswamy
233
F.
Sustainable Development/Environment / Menaka Guruswamy
236
G.
Tolerance and Education/Spirituality / Menaka Guruswamy
237
H.
Justice / Menaka Guruswamy
237
I.
Democracy / Menaka Guruswamy
238
J.
Secularism / Menaka Guruswamy
239
IV.
Prioritisation / Menaka Guruswamy
240
A.
Prioritisation: Creation of the Basic Structure Doctrine by the Supreme Court / Menaka Guruswamy
240
B.
Content of this 'Basic Structure' was Considered and Crafted on a Case-by-Case Basis / Menaka Guruswamy
240
C.
Prioritisation: Directive Principles and Fundamental Rights / Menaka Guruswamy
241
i.
Literal Approach / Menaka Guruswamy
242
ii.
Harmonious Construction / Menaka Guruswamy
243
iii.
Equally Important-The Balancing Act / Menaka Guruswamy
243
V.
Conclusion / Menaka Guruswamy
244
10.
Values in Iranian Constitutional Law / Menaka Guruswamy
247
I.
Context of Iranian Constitutional Values / Nazila Ghanea
247
A.
Constitutions and Values / Nazila Ghanea
247
B.
Historical Context / Nazila Ghanea
247
C.
Religious Context / Nazila Ghanea
249
D.
Political Context / Nazila Ghanea
251
II.
Values and their Prioritisation / Nazila Ghanea
252
A.
Values Contained in the Constitution / Nazila Ghanea
252
i.
Fairness, Justice / Nazila Ghanea
252
ii.
Freedom, Independence / Nazila Ghanea
253
iii.
Community, Family / Nazila Ghanea
254
iv.
Responsibility, Accountability / Nazila Ghanea
254
v.
Integrity, Honesty / Nazila Ghanea
255
vi.
Compassion, Caring / Nazila Ghanea
255
vii.
Respect, Tolerance / Nazila Ghanea
255
viii.
Reverence for Life / Nazila Ghanea
255
ix.
Spirituality / Nazila Ghanea
256
x.
Learning, Education / Nazila Ghanea
256
B.
Understanding these Values Conceptually / Nazila Ghanea
256
C.
Realising these Values-The Balance of Powers System / Nazila Ghanea
259
D.
'Human Rights' in the Constitution? / Nazila Ghanea
263
III.
Congruence and Priorities? / Nazila Ghanea
264
11.
Global Values and Local Realities: The Case of Israeli Constitutional Law / Nazila Ghanea
267
I.
Introduction: Values in Israeli Constitutional Law / Aeyal M. Gross
267
II.
Sources of Values / Aeyal M. Gross
269
A.
First Channel for Values: 1948-92 / Aeyal M. Gross
269
B.
Second Channel for Values: Since 1992 / Aeyal M. Gross
272
III.
Examining Values / Aeyal M. Gross
276
A.
Declaration of Independence / Aeyal M. Gross
276
B.
Basic Laws / Aeyal M. Gross
277
C.
Case Law / Aeyal M. Gross
278
i.
Human Dignity / Aeyal M. Gross
278
ii.
Fairness / Aeyal M. Gross
281
iii.
Equality / Aeyal M. Gross
281
iv.
Freedom / Aeyal M. Gross
283
v.
Tolerance / Aeyal M. Gross
284
vi.
Respect for Life / Aeyal M. Gross
286
vii.
Accountability and Integrity / Aeyal M. Gross
287
viii.
Education / Aeyal M. Gross
288
ix.
Family / Aeyal M. Gross
289
D.
Elephant in the Room: A Jewish Democratic State-Questions of Community, Participation and Inclusion / Aeyal M. Gross
292
E.
Elephant Outside: The Occupation and the Role of the Security Discourse / Aeyal M. Gross
295
IV.
Conclusion: Global Values in a Local Context / Aeyal M. Gross
299
12.
Japan / Aeyal M. Gross
303
I.
Context / Yasuo Hasebe
303
II.
Values in the Constitution of Japan / Yasuo Hasebe
303
A.
Fairness/Justice / Yasuo Hasebe
303
B.
Equality / Yasuo Hasebe
304
C.
Honesty/Integrity / Yasuo Hasebe
305
D.
Community / Yasuo Hasebe
305
E.
Family / Yasuo Hasebe
305
F.
Freedom/Liberty/Independence / Yasuo Hasebe
307
G.
Responsibility/Accountability / Yasuo Hasebe
307
H.
Compassion/Caring / Yasuo Hasebe
309
I.
Respect/Tolerance / Yasuo Hasebe
309
J.
Life / Yasuo Hasebe
310
K.
Security / Yasuo Hasebe
311
L.
Learning/Education / Yasuo Hasebe
311
M.
Dignity / Yasuo Hasebe
312
N.
Environment / Yasuo Hasebe
312
O.
Participation/Inclusion / Yasuo Hasebe
313
P.
Peace / Yasuo Hasebe
313
III.
Congruence / Yasuo Hasebe
314
A.
Judicial Review: Gap Between Text and Law / Yasuo Hasebe
314
B.
Constitutional Pacifism: Gap Between Value and Reality / Yasuo Hasebe
316
IV.
Conclusion / Yasuo Hasebe
318
13.
Values in the South African Constitution / Yasuo Hasebe
321
I.
Introduction / Catherine Albertyn
321
II.
Values / Catherine Albertyn
323
A.
Values in the South African Constitution / Catherine Albertyn
323
B.
Value Hierarchies? / Catherine Albertyn
324
III.
'Universal List' of Values / Catherine Albertyn
326
A.
Dignity / Catherine Albertyn
326
B.
Equality / Catherine Albertyn
330
C.
Freedom/Independence/Liberty / Catherine Albertyn
334
D.
Responsibility/Accountability / Catherine Albertyn
339
E.
Participation/Inclusion / Catherine Albertyn
340
F.
Life / Catherine Albertyn
341
G.
Community / Catherine Albertyn
343
H.
Fairness/Justice / Catherine Albertyn
345
I.
Family / Catherine Albertyn
346
J.
Integrity/Honesty / Catherine Albertyn
347
K.
Compassion/Caring / Catherine Albertyn
347
L.
Respect/Tolerance / Catherine Albertyn
348
M.
Security / Catherine Albertyn
350
N.
Learning/Education / Catherine Albertyn
350
O.
Environment / Catherine Albertyn
351
IV.
Values, Transformation and Courts / Catherine Albertyn
351
14.
Values in the UK Constitution / Catherine Albertyn
357
I.
Introduction and Context / Jeffrey Jowell Colm O'Cinneide
357
II.
Presumption of Liberty / Jeffrey Jowell Colm O'Cinneide
360
III.
Primacy of Representative Government (or Sovereignty of Parliament) / Jeffrey Jowell Colm O'Cinneide
363
IV.
Commitment to the Rule of Law / Jeffrey Jowell Colm O'Cinneide
368
V.
Resolution of Conflict Between the Presumption of Liberty, the Rule of Law and the Sovereignty of Parliament / Jeffrey Jowell Colm O'Cinneide
374
VI.
'Secondary' Constitutional Values and Their Impact on Public and Private Law / Jeffrey Jowell Colm O'Cinneide
377
A.
Respect for Individual Autonomy / Jeffrey Jowell Colm O'Cinneide
380
B.
Respect for Human Dignity / Jeffrey Jowell Colm O'Cinneide
382
C.
Equality / Jeffrey Jowell Colm O'Cinneide
383
D.
Tolerance / Jeffrey Jowell Colm O'Cinneide
385
E.
Transparency, Openness and Political Accountability / Jeffrey Jowell Colm O'Cinneide
387
F.
Effective Governance / Jeffrey Jowell Colm O'Cinneide
388
G.
Latent Values / Jeffrey Jowell Colm O'Cinneide
389
VII.
Conclusion-The Gap Between Values and Reality / Jeffrey Jowell Colm O'Cinneide
390
15.
Global Constitutional Values in the United States / Colm O'Cinneide Jeffrey Jowell
393
I.
Introduction / Ruti Teitel
393
II.
Founding Values / Ruti Teitel
393
A.
Freedom/Independence / Ruti Teitel
394
i.
Constitutional Incongruence / Ruti Teitel
395
B.
Equality / Ruti Teitel
396
i.
Constitutional Incongruence / Ruti Teitel
396
ii.
Prioritisation / Ruti Teitel
397
III.
Free Speech/Expression / Ruti Teitel
397
i.
Prioritisation and Congruence / Ruti Teitel
399
IV.
Freedom of Religious Exercise / Ruti Teitel
401
i.
Prioritisation and Congruence / Ruti Teitel
402
V.
Of Liberty and Due Process / Ruti Teitel
405
i.
Prioritisation and Congruence / Ruti Teitel
406
VI.
Privacy / Ruti Teitel
406
ii.
Congruence / Ruti Teitel
409
VII.
Evolution of Freedom in the Modern State / Ruti Teitel
410
i.
Prioritisation and Congruence / Ruti Teitel
412
A.
Debate Over Freedom of Contract / Ruti Teitel
413
i.
Prioritisation and Congruence / Ruti Teitel
414
VIII.
Conclusion / Ruti Teitel
415
16.
Global Values in the Venezuelan Constitution: Some Prioritisations and Several Incongruences / Ruti Teitel
417
I.
Introduction and Constitutional Background / Allan R. Brewer-Carias
417
II.
Constitutional Values and their Prioritisation / Allan R. Brewer-Carias
419
A.
Human Dignity / Allan R. Brewer-Carias
421
B.
Fairness/Justice/Rule of Law/State of Justice / Allan R. Brewer-Carias
424
C.
Equality/Respect/Tolerance/Diversity/Multiculturalism / Allan R. Brewer-Carias
425
D.
Democracy/Participation/Decentralisation/Inclusion / Allan R. Brewer-Carias
426
E.
Compassion/Caring/Solidarity/Social Justice/Social State / Allan R. Brewer-Carias
428
F.
Community/Civil Society / Allan R. Brewer-Carias
429
G.
Family / Allan R. Brewer-Carias
430
H.
Life / Allan R. Brewer-Carias
431
I.
Learning/Education / Allan R. Brewer-Carias
431
J.
Honesty/Integrity / Allan R. Brewer-Carias
432
K.
Freedom/Liberty/Independence / Allan R. Brewer-Carias
433
L.
Security / Allan R. Brewer-Carias
434
M.
Responsibility/AccountabilityfTransparency / Allan R. Brewer-Carias
434
N.
Environment / Allan R. Brewer-Carias
435
III.
Incongruences between Declared Values and Political and Judicial Practice / Allan R. Brewer-Carias
436
A.
Subjection of the Superior Values of the Constitution to its 'Political Project' and the Rejection of the Supra-Constitutional Rank of International Instruments on Human Rights / Allan R. Brewer-Carias
436
B.
Erosion of Public Participation in Political Decision Making / Allan R. Brewer-Carias
439
C.
Erosion of the Democratic Principle / Allan R. Brewer-Carias
441
D.
Contradictory State Intervention in the Internal Life of Civil Society Entities / Allan R. Brewer-Carias
442
E.
Dangerous Expansion of Security and Defence Values / Allan R. Brewer-Carias
444
IV.
Conclusion / Allan R. Brewer-Carias
446
17.
Conclusion / Allan R. Brewer-Carias
449
I.
Ambiguities: A Critical Assessment / Alan Richter Dennis Davis Cheryl Saunders
454
A.
Freedom/Independence / Cheryl Saunders Alan Richter Dennis Davis
454
B.
Family/Community / Dennis Davis Alan Richter Cheryl Saunders
455
C.
Respect/Tolerance / Dennis Davis Alan Richter Cheryl Saunders
455
D.
Democracy / Alan Richter Dennis Davis Cheryl Saunders
455
II.
Prioritisation of Ascribed Meanings / Dennis Davis Alan Richter Cheryl Saunders
455
III.
Congruence / Dennis Davis Alan Richter Cheryl Saunders
460
A.
Relationship Between Theory and Practice / Dennis Davis Alan Richter Cheryl Saunders
460
i.
Australia / Alan Richter Dennis Davis Cheryl Saunders
460
ii.
Brazil / Alan Richter Dennis Davis Cheryl Saunders
461
iii.
Canada / Dennis Davis Alan Richter Cheryl Saunders
461
iv.
China / Dennis Davis Alan Richter Cheryl Saunders
461
v.
Finland / Alan Richter Dennis Davis Cheryl Saunders
461
vi.
France / Dennis Davis Alan Richter Cheryl Saunders
462
vii.
Germany / Alan Richter Dennis Davis Cheryl Saunders
462
viii.
India / Dennis Davis Alan Richter Cheryl Saunders
462
ix.
Iran / Dennis Davis Alan Richter Cheryl Saunders
462
x.
Israel / Alan Richter Dennis Davis Cheryl Saunders
463
xi.
Japan / Dennis Davis Alan Richter Cheryl Saunders
463
xii.
South Africa / Dennis Davis Alan Richter Cheryl Saunders
463
xiii.
United Kingdom / Dennis Davis Alan Richter Cheryl Saunders
463
xiv.
United States / Dennis Davis Alan Richter Cheryl Saunders
463
xv.
Venezuela / Dennis Davis Alan Richter Cheryl Saunders
464
IV.
Where Does this Leave this Project? / Alan Richter Cheryl Saunders Dennis Davis
464
V.
Impartial Spectator / Alan Richter Dennis Davis Cheryl Saunders
467
VI.
Implications Which Flow From This Study / Alan Richter Dennis Davis Cheryl Saunders
469
VII.
Annexure: Law and Versteeg (2011) / Dennis Davis Alan Richter Cheryl Saunders
473
Index / Dennis Davis Alan Richter Cheryl Saunders
477