Building the constitution : the practice of constitutional interpretation in post-apartheid South Africa / James Fowkes, Institute for International and Comparative Law in South Africa, University of Pretoria, South Africa.
2016
KTL2620 .F69 2016 (Map It)
Available at Cellar
Formats
Format | |
---|---|
BibTeX | |
MARCXML | |
TextMARC | |
MARC | |
DublinCore | |
EndNote | |
NLM | |
RefWorks | |
RIS |
Items
Details
Author
Title
Building the constitution : the practice of constitutional interpretation in post-apartheid South Africa / James Fowkes, Institute for International and Comparative Law in South Africa, University of Pretoria, South Africa.
Published
Cambridge, United Kingdom : Cambridge University Press, 2016.
Call Number
KTL2620 .F69 2016
Former Call Number
So.Af 910 F829 2016
ISBN
9781107124097 (hardback)
1107124093 (hardback)
1107124093 (hardback)
Description
xxi, 392 pages ; 24 cm.
System Control No.
(OCoLC)951557405
Summary
"This revisionary perspective on South Africa's celebrated Constitutional Court draws on historical and empirical sources alongside conventional legal analysis to show how support from the African National Congress government and other political actors has underpinned the Court's landmark cases, which are often applauded too narrowly as merely judicial achievements. Standard accounts see the Court as overseer of a negotiated constitutional compromise and as the looked-to guardian of that constitution against the rising threat of the ANC. However, in reality South African successes have been built on broader and more admirable constitutional politics to a degree no previous account has described or acknowledged. The Court has responded to this context with a substantially consistent but widely misunderstood pattern of deference and intervention. Although a work in progress, this institutional self-understanding represents a powerful effort by an emerging court, as one constitutionally serious actor among others, to build a constitution"-- Provided by publisher.
Bibliography, etc. Note
Includes bibliographical references (pages 356-383) and index.
Record Appears in
Gift
Purchased from the income of the African Law Center Fund
Gift

The Arthur W. Diamond Law Library
Purchased from the income of the African Law Center Fund
Table of Contents
Acknowledgements
xi
Table of South African Cases
xiv
1.
Introduction
1
Beginning: Makwanyane Stories
6
Beyond Makwanyane
19
2.
Taking Reality (Legally) Seriously
26
Work of the Constitution-Building Court
30
Realism, Law and Karl Llewellyn
33
Strategy, Legal Legitimacy and Alexander Bickel
38
Dworkin, Ackerman and the Relevance of Political Activity to Interpretation
41
3.
Voting Rights, Politics and Trust
50
Rereading NNP
51
Constitution-Building Court at Work: Structural Concerns in NNP
56
Democracy and Trust
66
Epilogue to NNP
74
Consistency: NNP and the Rest of the Court's Voting Rights Jurisprudence
81
Another NNP v. ANC
88
4.
Role of the Court: Standard Conceptions
95
Intentions of the Drafters
96
Institutional Thinking during the Transition -- the ANC
99
Institutional Thinking during the Transition -- the NP and Other Minority Groups
103
Court as an Actor in an Elite Pact
110
Post-Apartheid Judging and Transformative Constitutionalism
121
Bridge-Building
126
5.
Role of the Court: Constitution-Building
129
Constitution-Building Account and Newness
131
Infrastructure
133
Public Status of Ideas
138
Illustration: HIV/AIDS Discrimination
142
Text and Its Questions: Constitution-Building as a Constitutional Argument
147
Purposive Text and Results-Driven Constitutionalism
150
6.
LGBTI Equality
156
Emerging Public Status of LGBTI Equality in South Africa
156
Two National Coalition Decisions: Criminalization and Immigration Law
163
Two Fourie Decisions: Same-Sex Marriage
168
Decisions to Decide, and Not to Decide: Family Law for Unmarried Couples
178
7.
Democracy
188
Doctors for Life
190
Extending the Lines: The Later Public Participation Cases
197
Promoting Democracy within Parliament and Local Government Structures
208
UDM (2) and the Brief Life of Floor-Crossing
216
Epilogue to UDM (2)
227
8.
Socio-economic Rights
233
Rights and Newness
233
Maximalism in Socio-economic Rights Cases: Grootboom, PE Municipality and Joseph
242
Non-intervention Decisions: Soobramoney, Nokotyana and Grootboom
252
Minister of Health v. Treatment Action Campaign
270
Mazibuko v. City of Johannesburg
287
9.
Equality, Eviction and Engagement
301
Promise of Legislative Action: Masiya and Volks v. Robinson
303
Deferring into Space: S v. Lawrence and S v. Jordan
312
Meaningful Engagement: Adjusting the Constitution-Building Equation
325
Engagement and Its Possibilities: From Eviction to Prince to the Future
340
Conclusion
349
Bibliography
356
Index
384