The law and politics of the Kosovo Advisory Opinion / edited by Marko Milanović and Michael Wood.
2015
KZ4264 .L39 2015 (Map It)
Available at Cellar
Formats
| Format | |
|---|---|
| BibTeX | |
| MARCXML | |
| TextMARC | |
| MARC | |
| DublinCore | |
| EndNote | |
| NLM | |
| RefWorks | |
| RIS |
Items
Details
Title
The law and politics of the Kosovo Advisory Opinion / edited by Marko Milanović and Michael Wood.
Published
Oxford, United Kingdom : Oxford University Press, 2015.
Call Number
KZ4264 .L39 2015
ISBN
9780198717515 (hardback)
0198717512 (hardback)
0198717512
0198717512 (hardback)
0198717512
Description
xv, 366 pages ; 24 cm
System Control No.
(OCoLC)884743399
Bibliography, etc. Note
Includes bibliographical references (pages 363-366) and index.
Record Appears in
Table of Contents
List of Abbreviations
xi
List of Contributors
xiii
1.
Introduction
1
I. The Advisory Proceedings In Context / Michael Wood Marko Milanovic
2.
Explaining Serbia's Decision to Go to the ICJ / Marko Milanovic Michael Wood
9
1.
Introduction / James Ker-Lindsay
9
2.
Declaration of Independence and Serbia's Response / James Ker-Lindsay
9
3.
Decision to Question Recognition or Secession / James Ker-Lindsay
13
4.
International Opposition to the Case / James Ker-Lindsay
14
5.
UN General Assembly Resolution / James Ker-Lindsay
16
6.
Conclusion / James Ker-Lindsay
18
3.
Arguing the Kosovo Case / James Ker-Lindsay
21
1.
Introduction / Marko Milanovic
21
2.
Pleadings in Brief / Marko Milanovic
22
3.
Outline of Arguments / Marko Milanovic
24
4.
Jurisdiction, Propriety, and the 'Question Question' / Marko Milanovic
27
5.
Arguments under General International Law / Marko Milanovic
32
6.
Arguments under Resolution 1244 / Marko Milanovic
44
7.
Conclusion / Marko Milanovic
58
4.
Practicalities of Representing a Client in Complex Multiparty Proceedings: The Example of Kosovo / Marko Milanovic
60
1.
Lead-Up to the Request / Qudsi Rasheed Michael Wood
60
2.
Practical Arrangements for Handling the Case / Qudsi Rasheed Michael Wood
65
3.
Kosovo's Participation in the Proceedings / Qudsi Rasheed Michael Wood
67
4.
Exchanges Among Like-Minded States / Qudsi Rasheed Michael Wood
68
5.
Conclusion / Qudsi Rasheed Michael Wood
72
5.
Settling of a Self-Determination Conflict? Kosovo's Status Process and the 2010 Advisory Opinion of the ICJ / Qudsi Rasheed Michael Wood
73
1.
Introduction / Bernhard Knoll-Tudor
73
2.
Statehood or Stasis? UNOSEK and the Contact Group / Bernhard Knoll-Tudor
74
3.
Miscalculations and Flawed Premises / Bernhard Knoll-Tudor
78
4.
Challenges to Serbia's Position / Bernhard Knoll-Tudor
81
5.
Spoiling the Party / Bernhard Knoll-Tudor
83
6.
UNOSEK's Settlement Proposal / Bernhard Knoll-Tudor
86
7.
Declaration of Independence, a New Constitution / Bernhard Knoll-Tudor
87
8.
ICJ's Advisory Opinion / Bernhard Knoll-Tudor
90
9.
Conclusion / Bernhard Knoll-Tudor
92
II. The Opinion / Bernhard Knoll-Tudor
6.
Questions of Jurisdiction and the Discretion to Decline a Request for an Advisory Opinion / Bernhard Knoll-Tudor
99
1.
Introduction / Vladimir Djeric
99
2.
Jurisdiction / Vladimir Djeric
100
3.
Discretion / Vladimir Djeric
104
4.
Conclusion / Vladimir Djeric
116
7.
Question Question / Vladimir Djeric
118
1.
Introduction / Daniel Müller
118
2.
Court's Refusal to Broaden the Scope of the Question / Daniel Müller
119
3.
Court's 'Corrections' to the Formulation of the Question / Daniel Müller
124
4.
Court's 'Interpretation' of the Meaning of the Question / Daniel Müller
128
5.
Concluding Remarks / Daniel Müller
132
8.
Reflections on the ICJ Advisory Opinion on Kosovo: Interpreting Security Council Resolution 1244 (1999) / Daniel Müller
134
1.
Introduction / Sean Murphy
134
2.
Core Legal Arguments Concerning the Consistency of the Declaration of Independence with Resolution 1244 / Sean Murphy
136
3.
Broader Ramifications of the Advisory Opinion for Interpretation and Application of Security Council Resolutions / Sean Murphy
156
4.
Conclusion / Sean Murphy
165
9.
UN Secretary-General and the Advisory Opinion / Sean Murphy
167
1.
Introduction / Mathias Forteau
167
2.
Not a Mere Secretariat / Mathias Forteau
169
3.
Neutrality as a Solution / Mathias Forteau
178
10.
Sounds of Silence: Making Sense of the Supposed Gaps in the Kosovo Opinion / Mathias Forteau
187
1.
Introduction / Marc Weller
187
2.
Is there a Prohibition of Unilateral Secession in International Law? / Marc Weller
190
3.
Is it Necessary to Rely on a Positive Right to Self-determination? / Marc Weller
196
4.
Is there a Right to Self-determination in the Sense of Secession Outside the Colonial Context? / Marc Weller
199
5.
Definition of the 'People' / Marc Weller
205
6.
Recognition of the People as Actors / Marc Weller
207
7.
Was there a Particular Prohibition of Secession Imposed by the Security Council? / Marc Weller
209
8.
Negotiating Process as a Source of Legitimacy? / Marc Weller
211
9.
What are the Implications of the Use of Force by NATO that Preceded the Eventual Declaration of Independence? / Marc Weller
212
10.
Conclusion / Marc Weller
214
III. Reactions And Implications / Marc Weller
11.
Court and its Multiple Constituencies: Three Perspectives on the Kosovo Advisory Opinion / Marc Weller
219
1.
Introduction / André Nollkaemper
219
2.
Institutional Perspective / André Nollkaemper
222
3.
Dispute Settlement Perspective / André Nollkaemper
229
4.
Guardian Perspective / André Nollkaemper
232
5.
Assessment / André Nollkaemper
238
12.
Political Aftermath of the ICJ's Kosovo Opinion / André Nollkaemper
240
1.
Introduction / Tatjana Papic
240
2.
Reactions to the Kosovo Advisory Opinion / Tatjana Papic
241
3.
UNGA Resolution on the Kosovo AO / Tatjana Papic
247
4.
Relations between Belgrade and Pristina-EU Sponsored Dialogue / Tatjana Papic
254
5.
Conclusion / Tatjana Papic
265
13.
Kosovo-The Questions Not Asked: Self-Determination, Secession, and Recognition / Tatjana Papic
268
1.
Pointless Question, Semi-Answer / Alain Pellet
268
2.
Right to Self-Determination of Non-Colonial Peoples / Alain Pellet
271
3.
Right to Secession v. Territorial Integrity / Alain Pellet
273
4.
Recognition by Other States / Alain Pellet
277
14.
Kosovo and the Criteria for Statehood in International Law / Alain Pellet
280
1.
Questions Avoided / James Crawford
280
2.
Application of the Criteria for Statehood to Kosovo / James Crawford
281
3.
Conclusion / James Crawford
290
15.
Has the Advisory Opinion's Finding that Kosovo's Declaration of Independence was not Contrary to International Law Set an Unfortunate Precedent? / James Crawford
291
1.
Introduction / Anne Peters
291
2.
Conceptual Issues: 'Uniqueness', 'Sui Generis', 'Precedent', and Distinguishing / Anne Peters
293
3.
Advisory Opinion as a Precedent? / Anne Peters
295
4.
DoI as a Precedent? / Anne Peters
300
5.
Possible Effects of 'No Precedent' Talk on the Evolution of International Customary Law / Anne Peters
305
6.
Normative Drawbacks of the 'No Precedent' Language / Anne Peters
309
7.
Conclusions / Anne Peters
311
IV. The Road Ahead / Anne Peters
16.
Some Implications of the Advisory Opinion for Resolution of the Serbia-Kosovo Conflict / Anne Peters
317
1.
Introduction / Richard Caplan Stefan Wolff
317
2.
Advisory Opinions and Conflict Resolution / Stefan Wolff Richard Caplan
318
3.
Further Recognition of Kosovo and its Effects / Richard Caplan Stefan Wolff
320
4.
Expanded International Engagement / Richard Caplan Stefan Wolff
322
5.
Shifts in Domestic Opinion, Politics, and Policy / Richard Caplan Stefan Wolff
327
6.
Growing Participation of Kosovo in the Society of States / Stefan Wolff Richard Caplan
328
7.
Conclusion / Stefan Wolff Richard Caplan
330
17.
Old Problems, Fresh Frameworks: Kosovo, Serbia and the EU-the Virtue of a 'Free Territory' / Richard Caplan Stefan Wolff
332
1.
Introduction / James Gow
332
2.
ICJ / James Gow
333
3.
Options for Kosovo / James Gow
335
4.
EU 'Free Territory' / James Gow
342
5.
Conclusion / James Gow
348
18.
Reflections on the Law and Politics of the Kosovo Case / James Gow
350
1.
Kosovo Case / Harold Hongju Koh
351
2.
Kosovo Precedent / Harold Hongju Koh
356
Bibliography / Harold Hongju Koh
363
Index / Harold Hongju Koh
367